Represent a stakeholder at an international sustainable cities summit. Defend your priorities, negotiate under pressure and agree on how to invest $300 million.
Your task: Work in a group of four to six. Each participant takes a different confidential role. Your committee must agree on a funding strategy that totals exactly $300 million and meets the community-benefit requirement.
The situation
The International Sustainable Cities Fund has $500 million available for investment in sustainable urban development. Three approaches are being considered. Your committee has been appointed to evaluate them and recommend an investment strategy.
Masdar-style development
A planned sustainable city emphasizing renewable energy, research, energy-efficient buildings and environmentally friendly transport.
Tianjin-style cooperation
An international eco-city partnership focusing on sustainable urban planning, resource management and environmentally friendly housing.
Liuzhou-style green development
An ambitious approach that integrates vegetation into buildings and urban spaces to improve environmental quality.
Your central dilemma
Should investment support new sustainable cities, international partnerships or the transformation of existing urban areas?
Five questions your committee must consider
Financial feasibility: Should governments invest heavily when economic returns are uncertain?
Environmental responsibility: Can a development be sustainable if construction itself causes environmental damage?
Social equality: Should innovation take priority over affordability and residents' needs?
Replicability: Can models from wealthy countries work in developing economies?
Urban priorities: Is it better to build new cities or transform existing ones?
Choose your group size
Four roles are essential. The fifth and sixth roles are added for larger groups.
Four role cards are available.
Confidential role cards
Important: Each participant should open only their own role card. Read it privately. Do not show the card to other committee members. You may choose what information to reveal during the discussion.
Select a role to reveal its private briefing. Roles 5 and 6 appear only when the group size allows them.
Confidential · For the assigned participant only
Preparation – 7 minutes
Before the meeting begins, prepare:
Your main position and the reasons behind it.
Two arguments to support your position.
One concern or objection you expect from another participant.
One concession you might be willing to make.
Do not plan to read a speech. Be ready to respond naturally to other people.
Committee negotiations
Your committee must examine the three approaches and decide what deserves investment. Each participant should explain their priorities, respond to challenges and explore possible compromises.
Stage 1 · Initial positionsEach participant presents their main concerns. Ask questions and identify areas of agreement and disagreement.
Stage 2 · Compare the proposalsDiscuss financial feasibility, environmental impact, social equality, replicability and the choice between new developments and existing-city regeneration.
Stage 3 · Respond to objectionsChallenge assumptions respectfully. Ask for evidence, explain trade-offs and consider alternatives.
Discussion prompts
Which proposal offers the most realistic long-term benefits?
Who might benefit from each development, and who might be disadvantaged?
Which elements could be transferred to other cities?
What should happen if environmental goals conflict with economic or social priorities?
What evidence would you need before approving an investment?
Optional discussion timer
12:00
Use the timer to keep the discussion moving. The teacher can adjust the duration by restarting it for each stage.
New information – Funding crisis
Read this announcement to the whole committee. The organization has lost 40% of its available investment budget. The fund has been reduced from $500 million to $300 million.
Additional condition
The organization now requires at least 30% of its investment to benefit existing urban communities.
Your committee must reconsider its original recommendation. You may change your priorities, revise your preferred approach or abandon a proposal entirely.
Renegotiation
Which parts of your original plan are no longer realistic?
What should be protected despite the reduced budget?
Can the three approaches be combined in a more cost-effective way?
How will you demonstrate that at least $90 million benefits existing urban communities?
What are you prepared to give up to reach agreement?
Prepare your final recommendation
Your committee must agree on a funding allocation totalling exactly $300 million. It must also explain how the community-benefit requirement will be met.
Funding allocation worksheet
Enter the amount your committee proposes to allocate to each development approach. The total must be exactly $300 million.
Current total: $300m. Community benefit: $120m.
The community-benefit figure may overlap with the three project allocations. It is a minimum earmarked benefit within the overall $300 million, not an additional fourth investment category.
C1 language support
Use these expressions to make your contributions more precise, diplomatic and persuasive.
Expressing reservations
I'm not entirely convinced that...
I have some reservations about...
Challenging an argument
Doesn't that overlook the fact that...?
I'm not sure that conclusion necessarily follows.
Qualifying a position
To some extent, I would agree that...
That may be true, provided that...
Introducing alternatives
An alternative worth considering would be...
We could approach this from a different angle.
Making concessions
I take your point, although...
I'm prepared to accept that, on the condition that...
Building consensus
Perhaps we could reach a compromise by...
We seem to agree on the principle that...
Evaluating consequences
This could have far-reaching implications for...
One possible unintended consequence is...
Expressing priorities
We need to strike a balance between...
Our overriding priority should be...
Teacher notes and assessment
Teacher-only section. Keep this page closed or do not project it while students are reading their confidential role cards.
Suggested 50-minute lesson sequence
5 minutes · Introduce the scenarioExplain the fund, the three approaches and the committee's task.
7 minutes · Individual preparationDistribute one different role to each participant. Students prepare privately.
12 minutes · Initial negotiationsStudents present priorities, explore disagreements and begin forming a proposal.
3 minutes · New developmentAnnounce the reduction to $300 million and the 30% community-benefit condition.
12 minutes · RenegotiationStudents revise their proposal and work towards consensus.
7 minutes · Final recommendationStudents present their allocation and justify the compromises they made.
4 minutes · FeedbackProvide feedback on argumentation, interaction, negotiation, fluency and critical thinking.
Assessment criteria
Argumentation Develops and defends ideas with relevant reasons and examples.
Interaction Responds to others, asks questions and builds on contributions.
Negotiation Makes concessions and works towards a shared decision.
Fluency and vocabulary Uses a broad range of language clearly and appropriately.
Critical thinking Evaluates consequences and recognizes competing interests.
Teacher-only answer guidance
There is no single correct allocation. A successful proposal must total exactly $300 million, earmark at least $90 million for benefits to existing urban communities, explain its priorities and acknowledge trade-offs. The community-benefit amount is included within the three project allocations, not added to them.