Your mandate
An international panel of scientists has identified four threats that could have serious consequences for human societies. Governments have established an emergency preparedness fund. Your committee has been asked to recommend how its limited resources should be distributed.
Your mandate: assess the risks, agree on priorities and present a recommendation that balances urgency, fairness and effectiveness.
Assign committee roles
For groups of three, combine the financial and policy adviser roles.
Facilitates discussion, invites quieter members and keeps the group on task.
Examines likelihood, scale and uncertainty.
Challenges whether proposed spending offers value for money.
Considers fairness, public impact and political feasibility.
Assess the four threats
Read the profiles. Discuss the scale and nature of each threat, then agree on an initial ranking.
Rising sea levels
Coastal flooding, erosion, damage to infrastructure, displacement and saltwater contamination of freshwater supplies.
Consider: exposure is uneven, but many consequences are already being experienced.
Desertification
Declining soil quality and agricultural productivity can undermine food security, livelihoods and ecosystem stability.
Consider: early intervention may prevent some damage, but recovery can be difficult.
Supervolcanic eruption
A very large eruption could inject enormous quantities of ash and gases into the atmosphere, disrupting climate and food systems.
Consider: the probability is extremely low, while potential consequences are severe.
Asteroid impact
A sufficiently large impact could cause catastrophic regional or global consequences. Detection and deflection may be possible with adequate warning.
Consider: the risk depends on object size, warning time and technological capability.
Allocate the preparedness budget
Your committee has 100 preparedness points. Distribute all 100 across the four threats. Each point represents a share of the available budget.
Your initial allocation is evenly distributed.
New evidence emerges
Your initial recommendation is challenged by three fictional briefing updates. Read each update in turn and decide whether your priorities should change.
Exposure assessment revised
A new assessment suggests that several densely populated coastal areas are more exposed to flooding than previously estimated. Adaptation projects could protect critical infrastructure, but the required investment is substantial.
Food systems under pressure
A prolonged drought has damaged harvests across several regions. Food prices are rising, and vulnerable communities face growing insecurity. Land restoration and water-management programmes could reduce future vulnerability, although results would take time.
A new object requires investigation
A newly detected near-Earth object requires further observation. Scientists cannot establish a credible impact probability from the available data. An international monitoring programme requests additional funding to improve tracking and response capacity.
Challenge your own position
Before finalising your recommendation, identify the strongest objections to it. Each member should challenge at least one part of the group's current thinking.
Present your final recommendation
Your committee must now submit a joint policy recommendation. Revisit the budget and agree on your final allocation.
Final allocation
Presentation checklist
- State your priorities clearly.
- Explain how probability and potential impact influenced your decision.
- Refer to the new evidence.
- Acknowledge at least one credible counterargument.
- Explain the trade-offs and limitations of your recommendation.
Teacher suggestion: allow approximately 45–55 minutes. For a shorter session, reduce the negotiation stage and ask groups to present only their strongest argument and one major trade-off.